Hello@GillespieGroupRealEstate.com   -   910.620.4380

Voted #1 Wilmington Real Estate Team by Wilmington NC Magazine

Moving to Wilmington? Get our "What Life Looks Like Here" newsletter. Subscribe 🌊

Waterfront houses along the Wilmington NC coast

Investment strategy guide · Wilmington area

Investment property and 1031 exchanges, from a team that invests here too.

Explore our guide to buying investment property, and to deferring capital gains tax through a 1031 exchange, in Carolina Beach, Kure Beach, Wilmington, and along the surrounding coast.

Start your investment search

Gillespie Group Real Estate, A Carolina One Company — Last updated

The highlights

Here's how a 1031 exchange works.

A 1031 exchange lets you sell an investment property and put the proceeds into another one while deferring capital gains tax, under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code. Here are the details.

45 days
From the day your original property sells, you have 45 days to identify replacement properties in writing. You can identify up to three properties of any value, or more under the 200% or 95% rules.
180 days
You have 180 days from that same sale to close on a replacement.
Qualified intermediary
The sale proceeds go to a qualified intermediary, not to you, and stay there until the replacement closes. Taking possession of the money ends the exchange.
Like-kind
Real property held for investment or business use exchanges for other real property held the same way. A home you live in as your primary residence doesn't qualify.

The IRS publishes its own overview in Like-Kind Exchanges, Real Estate Tax Tips.

Why here

A coastal market built for investors.

Wilmington and the beaches of Carolina Beach and Kure Beach draw a steady stream of buyers who want more than a second home. They want an asset that earns an ROI, whether that means a long-term rental, a short-term vacation property, or a piece of a larger portfolio moved here through a 1031 exchange. Year-round tourism and a growing population are what make this market so attractive.

On video · Why invest here

1031 guide video

Brittney's take · Why invest here

Why I recommend investing in Wilmington and Carolina Beach

Brittney's case for investing here, not just vacationing, from what she sees across Wilmington and Carolina Beach.

The investors we work with care less about the appreciation story than about whether the numbers work today. Property values, cash flow, and interest rates drive real buying decisions, so that's where every conversation with us starts.

Pick your model

Short-term or long-term rental: decide first.

The first decision for any Wilmington investor is whether a property works better as a short-term vacation rental or a long-term lease. That depends on the property, the area, and how hands-on you want to be.

If short-term is the plan in Carolina Beach or Kure Beach, our short-term rental investing guide for Carolina Beach and Kure Beach covers the zoning, covenants, taxes, and Vacation Rental Act rules that decide whether a specific property works.

On video · Rental strategy

1031 guide video Ny1irQev43Q

Danielle's take · Short-term rentals

How location affects short-term rental performance on Pleasure Island

Not every block in Carolina Beach and Kure Beach performs the same as a short-term rental. Danielle walks through why location within the island, not just the island itself, drives booking performance.

1031 guide video uZQONG3Gg5M

Brittney's take · Seasonal income

Carolina Beach off-season rental strategy: keep income flowing year-round

Summer bookings are the easy part. Brittney covers how owners keep income steady through Carolina Beach's slower months instead of treating the off-season as dead time.

1031 guide video SfE2UF3lVjw

Sara's take · Rental strategy

Short-term vs. long-term rentals in Wilmington: which is better?

Sara weighs short-term against long-term rentals in this market, and why the answer depends on the property and the owner's goals.

1031 guide video 1zgWciYBAZo

Brittney's take · Guest experience

Why guest experience makes or breaks your beach rental

Brittney manages both traditional and short-term rentals, and shows how the small details of a guest's stay turn into reviews, repeat bookings, and income.

Run your numbers

What a Wilmington rental earns.

Most rental calculators skip the costs that decide whether a coastal property produces a return. Flood insurance, named-storm deductibles, and a tax bill that can move after revaluation must be considered. Enter your own quotes for each one. If you're weighing replacement properties for a 1031 exchange, run each listing here before the 45-day identification deadline.

Purchase and financing

The offer price, or the list price to start.

From your lender's quote.

From your lender's quote.

The length of the loan your lender quoted.

Your lender's loan estimate shows this.

Income

From comparable long-term leases.

Time empty between leases, as a share of the year.

From comparable rentals in the same town.

Booked nights as a share of the year.

Needed when you enter a cleaning cost.

From a local cleaning quote.

From your booking platform's host fee schedule.

The coastal costs

Check the FEMA flood map or the elevation certificate.

From a flood quote, not an estimate.

From your insurance agent. Wind is often a separate policy.

We set aside one deductible every ten years, calculated on the purchase price.

From the county tax bill.

Extra tax if the county reassesses upward.

From the association's current budget.

Ask for the reserve study and the assessment history.

Operating

From a management company's quote, or zero if you self-manage.

What you set aside for repairs.

What you pay that the tenant or guest doesn't.

Add your purchase price, down payment, interest rate, loan term, monthly rent and flood zone to see your results.

Monthly cash flow
—
Cash-on-cash return
—
Cap rate
—
DSCR (debt service coverage)
—

Many lenders set a minimum. Ask yours what it is.

Break-even occupancy
—
What it costs to hold, per year
Line itemAnnual
Fills in as you enter costs.

Send us your numbers. We'll pressure-test the assumptions with you before you write an offer.

Email us your scenario

Estimates only, for illustration. Not tax, legal, lending, or insurance advice. Confirm insurance with a licensed agent, taxes with a CPA, and short-term rental rules with the town before you buy. Occupancy and sales taxes collected from guests are passed through and not counted as income.

Track record

The track record behind the advice.

Gillespie Group Real Estate is a boutique real estate team in the Wilmington, NC area, brokered by Carolina One Properties. Every agent on the team has bought, sold, or managed property with their own money on the line, so the numbers we run with you are the same ones we run on our own purchases.

#5
NC by sides
RealTrends Verified, 2025 sales data
#7
NC by volume
RealTrends Verified, 2025 sales data
141
Closed sides
2025
$67.15M
Closed volume
2025

Getting started

Choosing the right property type.

Single-family homes, condos, small multifamily properties, and land all play a different role in an investment strategy. A single-family home tends to be the simplest entry point and the easiest to finance. A condo trades some flexibility for lower upkeep. A small multifamily property spreads risk across more than one unit, which can steady cash flow when one unit sits vacant. Land carries the least immediate income but the most long-term optionality.

The right choice depends on what the property needs to do for you, whether that is monthly income, a future primary residence, or a long-term hold inside a portfolio.

On video · Property types

1031 guide video jHNOTubmkwY

Danielle's take · Condos vs. houses

Carolina Beach investment property: condos vs. houses for rental income

Danielle breaks down how condos and houses perform differently as rentals in Carolina Beach specifically, from HOA rules to maintenance costs to the kind of lease or booking each one supports.

1031 guide video jedYj0YtBYE

Brittney's take · Multifamily

Why Carolina Beach is a hidden gem for multifamily investing

The case for small multifamily property in Carolina Beach, the property type that spreads income across more than one unit.

1031 guide video vbZmaRCSyiA

Sara's take · Second homes and investment

Second home or investment? Why not both

How one property in Wilmington or Carolina Beach can be a second home part of the year and a rental the rest, if it's structured that way from the start.

Where to buy

Comparing areas.

Wilmington, Carolina Beach, and the areas around them each run on a different mix of demand, from year-round leases to summer weeks, and each returns differently. Choose the area for the strategy behind the purchase, not just the property.

On video · Area comparison

1031 guide video LdNth4cCRkY

Brittney's take · Location comparison

Downtown Wilmington vs. Carolina Beach investment property

Brittney compares what each area actually delivers for an investor, from lease and booking demand to how each market behaves differently even though they're only a short drive apart.

1031 guide video 5cBhYBG0V9c

Danielle's take · Carolina Beach

Best Carolina Beach investment for 3-5 years? What to buy now

What Danielle would buy in Carolina Beach for a shorter, 3 to 5 year hold.

1031 guide video sEVX8Gl C1I

Sara's take · Near UNCW

Investing near UNCW: why Wilmington's student rental market is booming

Sara walks through what's driving off-campus rental demand near UNCW, and what that means for how a property near campus is priced and leased.

Before you buy

Financing an investment purchase.

Financing an investment property is not the same process as financing a home you plan to live in. Lenders generally require a larger down payment, apply stricter qualifying standards, and weigh projected rental income alongside your own finances. Get pre-approved as an investor, not just as a buyer, before you start touring. Then never waive an inspection, and build a realistic estimate of maintenance, vacancy, and management costs into your projections rather than assuming best-case income every month of the year.

On video · Financing

1031 guide video kkimwrZtfJU

Danielle's take · Before you buy

What you need to know before buying a second home in Wilmington

Danielle covers the groundwork worth doing before you ever make an offer, from financing readiness to the questions that separate a good second home from one you'll regret.

1031 guide video 5H8EqvjVWHo

Sara's take · Rental performance

The real reason some rental properties crush it while others sit empty

Sara breaks down what actually separates a rental that stays booked from one that sits vacant, and why it usually comes down to decisions made before the purchase, not after.

The tax-deferred strategy

1031 exchanges, explained by Danielle.

Danielle Gillespie, our Team Lead and Realtor, has walked buyers through the exchange process in Carolina Beach and Kure Beach for years. Here's what she wants every investor to know before they start.

On video · 1031 exchanges

1031 guide video

Danielle's take · Who qualifies

Who actually qualifies for a 1031 exchange?

Who a 1031 exchange is actually for

A good candidate for someone to do a 1031 exchange is literally anybody that has a real estate asset that they want to sell and avoid capital gains tax. If you can put in a little bit of effort and figure out a location that you want to invest in, it can be extremely beneficial. As long as you can crunch some numbers and dedicate some time to find locations and look at some real estate, it works for anyone who's looking to avoid some taxes.

Danielle Gillespie, Team Lead and Realtor
1031 guide video xNCrmQO P3g

Danielle's take · 1031 exchanges

Thinking about a 1031 exchange at the beach? Here's what you need to know

The clock starts the moment you sell

If you are thinking about doing a 1031 exchange here at the beach, one of the most important things you need to keep in mind is your 45 day time clock in order to solidify a home. That is the biggest hurdle that I find most buyers need to overcome.

Danielle Gillespie, Team Lead and Realtor
1031 guide video KXUiukLMcAY

Danielle's take · The 45-day rule

The 1031 exchange mistake that costs investors the most

The mistake most buyers make

One of the mistakes that I see people make when they're getting ready to do a 1031 exchange is forget about the 45 day identification window that you have once you sell that previous asset. From the time that you sell a property that you're 1031 exchanging, you only have 45 days to identify up to usually four properties that you intend to purchase. Now you have up until 6 months to actually make the purchase, but only 45 days to actually identify, and then you have to purchase one of those. If you're not coming in prepared, it can feel like an extreme time crunch, and sometimes people will settle.

Danielle Gillespie, Team Lead and Realtor

Common questions

Investment property and 1031 exchanges, answered.

How does a 1031 exchange work?

A 1031 exchange lets you sell an investment property and reinvest the proceeds into a new one while deferring capital gains tax, under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code. The sale proceeds are held by a qualified intermediary rather than by you, the replacement property must be identified within 45 days of the sale, and the purchase must be completed within 180 days total.

What should I know about a 1031 exchange in North Carolina?

Around Wilmington, Carolina Beach, and Kure Beach, the two things that trip up out-of-state buyers most are the 45-day window to identify a replacement property and the fact that a qualified intermediary, not the seller, has to hold the sale proceeds the entire time.

How long do I have to find a replacement property in a 1031 exchange?

From the date the original property sells, you have 45 days to identify up to three potential replacement properties in writing (or more under the 200% or 95% rules), and up to 180 days total from the original sale to close on one of them. The 45-day window is the step most buyers underestimate.

Who is a good candidate for a 1031 exchange?

Any owner of a real estate asset who wants to sell and defer capital gains tax can be a good candidate, as long as they are prepared with a target location and ready to move quickly once the 45-day identification window opens.

Who handles 1031 exchange purchases in the Wilmington area?

Gillespie Group Real Estate, A Carolina One Company, works with 1031 exchange buyers across the Wilmington area. We have guided investors through the exchange process in Carolina Beach, Kure Beach, and the greater Wilmington market, and we walk every 1031 client through the identification timeline before they sell.

Is buying an investment property different from buying a home to live in?

Yes. Investment property financing typically requires a larger down payment and stricter qualifying standards than an owner-occupied purchase, and the property is evaluated on projected rental income and expenses in addition to your own budget.

Should I buy a rental property for cash flow or appreciation?

Cash flow first. We look at property values, cash flow potential, and interest rates before the appreciation story. A property that covers its own expenses and produces income tends to be a steadier foundation than one bought on the hope of future appreciation alone.

What does an investment property cost beyond the purchase price?

Budget for inspection and due diligence costs, ongoing maintenance and vacancy periods, property management if you are not local, and insurance and tax obligations specific to a rental or investment property.

On the coast, flood insurance is always a separate policy, and wind coverage often is too, so get quotes for both before you're under contract. The calculator above lets you run those costs against your own numbers.

Who should I contact about investment property or a 1031 exchange in Wilmington?

Danielle Gillespie, Sara Darby, and Brittney Roseberry all work with investment property buyers on the team. Reach out to whichever agent fits your situation.

This guide is general information about investment property and 1031 exchanges in the Wilmington area, not tax, legal, or financial advice, and it doesn't create an agency relationship. Confirm the details of any exchange with a qualified intermediary and your own CPA or tax attorney before you sell.

Working with us

Meet the team that invests here too.

Portrait of Danielle Gillespie
Danielle Gillespie
Team Lead, Realtor · License #308134

“Wilmington investment buyers come to me wanting a plan, not just a listing. Whether it's a first rental property on Pleasure Island or a portfolio move through a 1031 exchange, I walk clients through the real numbers before we ever step into a house, because the right property only works if it works for what you actually need it to do.”

Carolina Beach and Kure Beach, second homes, vacation rentals, and 1031 exchange properties. Licensed since 2018, with a Master's in Finance and her own investment portfolio.

Gillespie Group Real Estate
A Carolina One Company
Danielle@GillespieGroupRealEstate.com
910.620.4380
Meet Danielle
Portrait of Sara Darby
Sara Darby
Realtor · License #335482

“Every investment conversation I have starts with the same question: what does this property need to earn for you, and by when? I've built my own rental portfolio here in Carolina Beach and downtown Wilmington, so I know the difference between a property that looks good on paper and one that actually performs, and that's the lens I bring to every client search.”

Co-owner of Coast and Capital Management, with rental properties in Carolina Beach and downtown Wilmington. Investor, first-time buyer, and relocation clients.

Gillespie Group Real Estate
A Carolina One Company
Sara@GillespieGroupRealEstate.com
910.520.8768
Meet Sara
Portrait of Brittney Roseberry
Brittney Roseberry
Realtor · License #332145

“I want my investment clients to feel like they have a partner who's thinking three steps ahead, not just someone opening doors. Between traditional rentals and short-term rental markets across Wilmington and Carolina Beach, I help clients figure out which strategy actually fits the property and the neighborhood, not just which one sounds best.”

Owns and operates two 1940s duplexes as short-term rentals in Carolina Beach, so her read on multifamily investing comes from firsthand ownership and day-to-day operations.

Gillespie Group Real Estate
A Carolina One Company
Brittney@GillespieGroupRealEstate.com
302.535.7450
Meet Brittney

Your investment strategy starts here

Ready to talk numbers?

Whether you're buying your first rental property or moving a portfolio through a 1031 exchange, we'll walk through the numbers with you before you make a move.

See investment properties

Planning an exchange? Email us about your 1031 timeline.