
Cape Fear Homeowners to See Insurance Rate Hikes Starting June 2025: Here's What You Can Do!
The legal dispute gets a settlement
Homeowners in our Wilmington region will see increases in their homeowners' insurance rates beginning June 1, 2025. The North Carolina Department of Insurance (NCDOI) announced a settlement with insurance companies on January 17th, resulting in rate hikes ranging from 5% to 16%, depending on your location in the Cape Fear area.
For residents in the beach areas of New Hanover, Brunswick, and Pender counties, the increase will be 16% this year. Meanwhile, the eastern parts of our coastal area will face a 10.5% increase, and western coastal areas will see a 5% jump. Check the chart to find your rate by zip code.
This settlement finalized after a legal dispute with the N.C. Rate Bureau, actually represents a compromise, as the bureau initially requested rate increases as high as 99.4% for certain coastal areas. While state officials, including Insurance Commissioner Mike Causey, emphasized that the outcome is better than it could have been, critics argue that the system remains flawed and disproportionately impacts coastal homeowners.
Is there good news?
We promise, we went searching for it. And, the good news is the settlement prohibits additional rate increase requests until June 2027, a move Commissioner Causey highlighted as a significant victory for homeowners, saving an estimated $777 million over the next two years compared to the bureau’s original proposal.
We are always in favoring of saving money so this is the bright spot in this news.

What can you do about it? Or maybe, what should you do about this.
Wilmington Biz Journal covered the settlement news and shared a tip from local insurance agent Jared Cranford from Wells Insurance, who stated, "While the statewide average increase is 15% over two years, individual rates may be much higher depending on location and other factors."
Here at the Gillespie Group we believe the best thing you can do is start talking with your insurance provider now to understand what your rate will be increasing to. This is also a great time to explore your options so you can manage the increases effectively.
In addition to the increased premium, discuss in detail what your coverage includes. Many policies have exclusions for specific risks - that if you want coverage for - might require a separate policy.
Final Thoughts from Us
Proactivity is what we are recommending. Get ahead of the insurance hike and start evaluating your policy today. If you are looking for great local resources in our area, reach out to us, and we’ll connect you with professionals to help you navigate through your options based on your location.

